• First Reference
  • About us
  • Contact us
  • Blog Signup 📨

First Reference Talks

Discussions on Human Resources, Employment Law, Payroll and Internal Controls

  • Home
  • About
  • Archives
  • Conference
  • Resources
  • Buy Policies
You are here: Home / Business / Evidence: employer vs. employee

By Andrew Lawson | 2 Minutes Read September 14, 2010

Evidence: employer vs. employee

Your credibility is judged by how consistent your story is with common sense.

Frequently asked questions at my training workshops:

  • How do I prove it?
  • It’s my word against the employee’s, right?
  • Why should the tribunal believe me?
  • Don’t they always side with the worker?

Proof “beyond a reasonable doubt” belongs to television drama!

You need to establish your case on a “balance of probabilities.”

Balance of . . . what?

Picture a teeter-totter or see-saw in a child’s playground—

Put all your evidence on one end . . . All of the employee’s evidence on the other end.

Now—look at both sides.

seesaw

The side with the heavier weight wins!

Whose story is most probable?

  • Is your story believable to an average person?
  • Do your documents match the evidence you give verbally?
  • Do all your witnesses give similar evidence?
  • Is your evidence rehearsed and too perfect? Not good.

Honesty and sincerity is not enough. You must be clear, detailed and consistent with the majority of the other evidence.

Your credibility only matters if your information is relevant. In Friesen v. Fish Bay Seafood, the worker’s religious leader (pastor) testified in a human rights case that involved freedom of religion. The tribunal did not give any weight to his evidence. He was a very credible witness but his evidence had nothing to do with the worker’s performance at work.

Your credibility really matters when your information contradicts that of the other side: Does your verbal evidence at the hearing line up with what you documented months earlier?

The information you provide must be directly related to the issues: You must be direct, open, and tell a story that flows easily

Your credibility is judged by how consistent your story is with common sense.

Note: a tribunal may accept any of your evidence, none of it or some of it at its own discretion.

Andrew Lawson
Health and Safety/Human Rights Advisor, Learn Don’t Litigate
www.learndl.ca

  • About
  • Latest Posts
Follow me
Andrew Lawson
Trainer and advisor at Learn Don't Litigate
Andrew Lawson is a human rights and health and safety trainer and advisor, currently consulting to both the federal and Ontario governments. Since 1996, he has conducted extensive legal research in the areas of human rights and occupational health and safety law. He has worked in the people management business for over 25 years.
Follow me
Latest posts by Andrew Lawson (see all)
  • Responding to a human rights complaint - September 5, 2012
  • Ontario policy on competing human rights - August 8, 2012
  • What does the case of Trayvon Martin tell us about racism in Canada? - April 4, 2012

Article by Andrew Lawson / Business, Employee Relations / balance of probabilities, beyond a reasonable doubt, canadian employment law, court evidence, Dismissal, employee, employer, employment law, evidence, Friesen v. Fish Bay Seafood, lawsuit, proof, terminations, wrongful dismissal

Share with a friend or colleague

Get the Latest Posts in your Inbox for Free!

About Andrew Lawson

Andrew Lawson is a human rights and health and safety trainer and advisor, currently consulting to both the federal and Ontario governments. Since 1996, he has conducted extensive legal research in the areas of human rights and occupational health and safety law. He has worked in the people management business for over 25 years.

Footer

About us

Established in 1995, First Reference is the leading publisher of up to date, practical and authoritative HR compliance and policy databases that are essential to ensure organizations meet their due diligence and duty of care requirements.

First Reference Talks

  • Home
  • About
  • Archives
  • Conference
  • Resources
  • Buy Policies

Main Menu

  • About First Reference
  • Resources
  • Contact us
  • 1 800 750 8175

Stay Connected

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

We welcome your comments on our blog articles. However, we do not respond to specific legal questions in this space.
We do not provide any form of legal advice or legal opinion. Please consult a lawyer in your jurisdiction or try one of our products.


Copyright © 2009 - 2022 · First Reference Inc. · All Rights Reserved
Legal and Copyright Notices · Publisher's Disclaimer · Privacy Policy · Accessibility Policy