• First Reference
  • About us
  • Contact us
  • Blog Signup 📨

First Reference Talks

Discussions on Human Resources, Employment Law, Payroll and Internal Controls

  • Home
  • About
  • Archives
  • Conference
  • Resources
  • Buy Policies
You are here: Home / Business / Missing comma means millions in overtime pay

By Apolone Gentles, JD, CPA,CGA, FCCA, Bsc (Hons) | 2 Minutes Read April 3, 2017

Missing comma means millions in overtime pay

comma“For want of a comma, we have this case.” This from one of the Judges in O’Connor et al v Oakhurst Dairy et al (Oakhurst).
The comma in question is known as the Oxford Comma, the Harvard Comma, or the serial comma. In a list of items, the Oxford Comma is the one placed just before the “and” or the “or” which joins the last item in the list. For example:

Sentence without the Oxford Comma Sentence with Oxford Comma
I like apples, bananas and pears. I like apples, bananas, and pears.

In many cases, omitting the Oxford Comma will not cause confusion. In the example above, in the context of a discussion about fruits, both sentences are equally clear.
However, omitting the Oxford comma in the following sentence could lead to ambiguity:

Sentence without the Oxford Comma Ambiguity – what are the names of the firms?
She has worked at several firms, including Hazlewoods, Cooper and Brown and Fisher. 1.       Hazlewoods
2.       Cooper and Brown
3.       Fisher
1.       Hazlewoods
2.       Cooper
3.       Brown and Fisher

Oakhurst

Oakhurst involved an ambiguity in a Maine statute dealing with overtime pay. Under the statute, employees involved in certain activities were exempt from the overtime provisions, so they were not entitled to overtime pay. A group of drivers in Oakhurst argued that they were entitled to overtime pay.
The overtime provision related to the activities of “packing” and “distribution” could be interpreted in two ways:

The overtime provision Interpretation 1 Interpretation 2
Overtime protection does not apply to:
“The canning, processing, preserving, freezing, drying, marketing, storing, packing for shipment or distribution of:
(1)    Agricultural produce;
(2)    Meat and fish products; and
(3)    Perishable foods.”
No overtime pay for a driver who is involved in the single activity of “packing”, whether the “packing” is for “shipment” or for “distribution”. No overtime pay for a driver who is involved in either of two activities – the first being “packing for shipment” and the second being “distribution”.

The drivers picked Interpretation 1; they did not pack for shipment or distribution, therefore the exemption from overtime pay did not apply to them, and consequently, they are entitled to overtime pay.
Their employer picked Interpretation 2; the drivers engaged in distribution, therefore the exemption from overtime pay applied to the drivers, and consequently, they are not entitled to overtime pay.
The Court applied rules of construction and grammar, and statutory interpretation tools, and concluded that Interpretation 1 applied; the drivers did not engage in the single activity of “packing for shipment or distribution”, and consequently, the drivers are entitled to overtime pay.
Had the provision included an Oxford Comma after shipment, so that it read “packing for shipment, or distribution of:”, the outcome might have been different. An overwhelming number of writing authorities recommend using the Oxford Comma to avoid ambiguity.

  • About
  • Latest Posts
Apolone Gentles, JD, CPA,CGA, FCCA, Bsc (Hons)
Apolone Gentles is a CPA, CGA and Ontario lawyer and editor with over 20 years of business experience. Apolone is leveraging 20 years of business and accounting experience to build a commercial litigation practice with an emphasis on construction law. She has held senior leadership roles in non-profit organizations, leading finance, human resources, information technology and facilities teams. She has also held senior roles in audit and assurance services at a “Big Four” audit firm. Apolone has also lectured in Auditing, Economics and Business at post-secondary schools.
Latest posts by Apolone Gentles, JD, CPA,CGA, FCCA, Bsc (Hons) (see all)
  • Risk management for not-for-profits - June 8, 2022
  • Disaster recovery essentials for IT departments - May 4, 2022
  • Segregation of duties and accounts payable - April 6, 2022

Article by Apolone Gentles, JD, CPA,CGA, FCCA, Bsc (Hons) / Business, Finance and Accounting, Not for Profit, Payroll / comma, Harvard Comma, legal writing, O'Connor et al v Oakhurst Dairy et al, overtime, overtime exemptions, overtime pay, Oxford Comma, Payroll, serial comma, statutory interpretation

Share with a friend or colleague

Get the Latest Posts in your Inbox for Free!

About Apolone Gentles, JD, CPA,CGA, FCCA, Bsc (Hons)

Apolone Gentles is a CPA, CGA and Ontario lawyer and editor with over 20 years of business experience. Apolone is leveraging 20 years of business and accounting experience to build a commercial litigation practice with an emphasis on construction law. She has held senior leadership roles in non-profit organizations, leading finance, human resources, information technology and facilities teams. She has also held senior roles in audit and assurance services at a “Big Four” audit firm. Apolone has also lectured in Auditing, Economics and Business at post-secondary schools.

Footer

About us

Established in 1995, First Reference is the leading publisher of up to date, practical and authoritative HR compliance and policy databases that are essential to ensure organizations meet their due diligence and duty of care requirements.

First Reference Talks

  • Home
  • About
  • Archives
  • Conference
  • Resources
  • Buy Policies

Main Menu

  • About First Reference
  • Resources
  • Contact us
  • 1 800 750 8175

Stay Connected

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

We welcome your comments on our blog articles. However, we do not respond to specific legal questions in this space.
We do not provide any form of legal advice or legal opinion. Please consult a lawyer in your jurisdiction or try one of our products.


Copyright © 2009 - 2022 · First Reference Inc. · All Rights Reserved
Legal and Copyright Notices · Publisher's Disclaimer · Privacy Policy · Accessibility Policy