First Reference company logo

First Reference Talks

News and Discussions on Payroll, HR & Employment Law

decorative image

Lawyer receives $1,000 for four minute wait constituting human rights breach



The Human Rights Tribunal of Ontario recently awarded an Ontario lawyer, Andrew Sprague, $1,000 for injury to dignity, feelings and self-respect, as a result of his being stopped from entering the Riocan Empress Walk mall with his service dog. At the time, the dog, Flicka, was wearing a blue vest, which identifies her as a services animal and which carries her certification information. Nevertheless, Sprague was stopped at the entrance to the mall, on the basis that the dog may not be allowed to enter.

Factoring into Sprague’s human rights complaint was the fact that he was accompanied by his wife, who was nine months pregnant. They were required to stand in the entrance to the mall while security watched them on the video camera, supposedly “seeking clarification” from a supervisor. During this time, Sprague grew concerned about his wife, who was in physical distress, and ultimately had to go speak with a supervisor himself in order to be permitted to enter the building.

In the end, the couple was allowed to enter the mall on the basis that the dog was, in fact, a service dog, but the circumstances of this short but unpleasant delay cost the mall’s owner, Riocan, $1,000 in damages. The security officers’ failure to recognize the legitimacy of the service animal and their public embarrassment of the couple who were stopped for this reason and made to wait in view of the other shoppers, constituted a breach of Sprague’s protected rights under the Ontario Human Rights Code.

By Marty Rabinovitch and Michelle Stephenson, Student-at-Law, Devry Smith Frank LLP

Follow me

Devry Smith Frank LLP

Employment and labour lawyers at Devry Smith Frank LLP
Devry Smith Frank LLP (DSF) is the largest full service law firm in Toronto outside of the downtown core. They offer a broad range of legal services to individual, business and corporate clients in most areas of corporate and personal law. Their firm’s employment law group covers a broad spectrum of HR law, including employment and labour law, occupational health & safety, human rights, workers’ compensation and much more.Lawyers at Devry Smith Frank LLP lead by Marty Rabinovitch B.A.H., LL.B. will be covering issues surrounding employment and labour law and human rights on First Reference Talks. They also provide training, seminars and conferences on the above topics. Read more .
Follow me

Latest posts by Devry Smith Frank LLP (see all)

, , , , , , , , ,

Comments are currently closed.